Marvel Studios’ latest superhero movie Black Panther is proving to be a box office beast, pulling in audiences and on a trajectory to become the number 2 or 3 performing movie. (With dethroning Marvel’s: The Avengers not outside the realm of possibility.)
In addition to having a great script, sharp characters, exciting actions, and powerful performances, Black Panther had grabbed people by the heart with its vision of Wakanda, a fictional nation in the heart of Africa untouched by colonialism. For people of the African Diaspora the notion of a nation like Wakanda has proven to be powerful and liberating, but there have been people, such as Ben Shapiro, who have dismissed the emotional connection with a patronizing “Wakanda is not real.”
Of course Wakanda is not real.
Do you know what else isn’t real?
Camelot is not real.
Hercules is not real.
Paris, Helen, Achilles and Odysseus are not real.
The power of myth is not that it is real, that is history’s job, but rather myth informs us of who we are and more importantly who we want to be. Through myth people speak about the values that matter and the aspirations worth struggles and sacrifice.
Wakanda is a modern myth for people bereft of their own. For far far too many people of the African Diaspora genealogy is an impossibly, the Atlantic slave trade obliterated their history and their connection to myth. Make no mistake the attraction to Wakanda is not about the comic-book technology, the fictional metals, but rather about a culture that had flourished as its own culture, that celebrates its own people, that inspires without hand me downs from alien lands.
Something as simple has hair is fraught with the influences of colonialism and the horrors of the past. I can’t imagine enforcing a rule that expels students for natural hair and yet today such practices are too common, so a place where hair that has not been straightened and made to appear European is powerful symbol. The Wakanda myth runs far deeper than hair and appearance but it is not my myth and much of symbolism can only be an intellectual exercise for me, and one of empathy as I try to understand my fellow human beings and the world as they experience it.
I will close out this short essay with one more reference to someone who is not real.
Captain America is not real. Captain America does not represent the slaughter of native, he does not represent slavery, or Jim Crow, or any number of other ills that our country has participated in, but rather he is what we hope we can be, what our ideals demand of us. If people like Ben Shapiro cannot see that Wakanda and Captain America are really the same thing for different peoples it displays their terrible inability to see the world in any way other than their own.
I would hesitate to place any bets on that horse. His analytical skills are lacking, his engages in factual distortions, and speaks to artistic intent without any citation or support.
Since I haven’t seen the movie Black Panther, I don’t have any particular opinions about it.
Ben and I do seem to share some similar tastes about movies though. He echoed my own feelings about the movie Get Out, that it was a very good movie, and also a racist movie.
I’ve been watching Ben’s videos for weeks now. And I think he is an impressive and honest spokesman for the conservative political viewpoint. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if he rises to greater success than Rush Limbaugh ever did.
Before I read your accusation against Ben Shapiro’s opinion of the Black Panther movie, I had seen for myself what Shapiro had actually said. His own words are his best defense, which is why I posted the links without comment.
Very unimpressive arguments and gross distortions the video are unpersuasive.
Do you have any thoughts of your own?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amBLGrRxjw0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKVfHe6kTU8